Tips for painting plastic so it won’t fade or chip. Is painting plastic worth the effort? Will it last, fade, or chip off? What are the best ways to paint plastic? How can the life of painted plastic be extended?
This post may contain affiliate links. Using these links helps support my blog. Thank you!
Back in August 2015, I posted about painting an old Little Tikes plastic playhouse that we found next to the dumpster at our gym. Since then, I’ve experimented with painting other plastic items and I wanted to check in with how the paint has held up over time. I’m going to cover more than just the playhouse as I’d like to give some comparisons. At the end, I’ll give you my thoughts and recommendations for painting plastic.
This is like the reverse before and after photos… haha.
The Little Tikes Playhouse Paint Job: 1.5 Years Later
This is the “Before” Picture:
These are some pictures from the painted plastic playhouse almost two years later. As you can see, the roof took the brunt of the wear. The acrylic had a lot of wear too (I’ll show you that toward the end of the post).
Seam areas were more apt to scrape off… having some serious regrets about the ugly acrylic job I did on the tire and ATM machine.
This side looks pretty good. I just had some issues with the edges of the hoop.
The dark blue looks, by far, the best. We’ll talk more about that in a moment. But I think I may have put more layers on that side too because it was so hard to cover the red.
Here’s the “big picture” though… as you can tell, it still looks decent from afar, considering it’s had almost two years of weathering and children.
The Superman Car
I believe this was my first attempt to paint plastic. I used Krylon plastic paint. The finished car was kept in the garage when not in use. It definitely had a lot of peeling and chipped paint, although it was still looking good enough last year that I’m sure some little boy or girl enjoyed it very much.
This is just the before picture though… no after available unfortunately.
Planters from Cat Litter Containers
Last June, I found some free cat litter containers off Freecycle and went crazy painting them, then adding vinyl with cute quotes to make planters. These came out so cute. I used a lot of Krylon plastic paint that I had sitting around, but I believe one or two were painted with Rustoleum 2x. As such, I can’t say that the peeling is 100% due to the paint, but the storage method was a bigger issue. Over the winter, I stacked them and I believe that caused paint to chip off. The 651 still looks great though.
This is the pictures with the fresh paint…
These are the “After” photos… less than a year later. I think the darker blue needed an additional layer of paint before I used it, but it seemed to have stood up to time better than the others. I believe this used the Rustoleum 2x rather than the Krylon plastic paint that I used for the two on the right.
I also think painting the inside of this was probably overkill.
Ride On Toy: Plasma Car
This is the original paint job…
This is the after picture… as you can see, not a big difference in how it looks. Woohoo! I used the same Rustoleum spray paint that I used on the playhouse.
Recommendations for Paint Type, Technique, Color Choice, and Storage
I have some thoughts about what worked best and what didn’t. Hopefully these recommendations will help y’all decide if painting is the right choice for you, and help you decide on the right type of paint, technique, and storage.
Overall, I recommend painting plastic if the item will otherwise end up in a landfill- or passing them on to someone else. I’m a big fan of reusing old items until they are absolutely dead before tossing them. While the paint has, in these cases, had some wear and tear, I can’t say that they had worse wear and tear than these items do on their own (with the original manufacturers coat of paint). In reality, how long does the paint last on items that are kept outdoors? I think I usually see a max of one year before the paint fades on plastic toys if they’re kept outside, but this depends on the product and color too (more on that below).
So if it’s between getting a faded playhouse free or cheap and spending a few hours painting it, or buying a brand new playhouse for hundreds of dollars, I’d lean towards doing the work. You save a lot of money and if you have to repaint every couple of years, so what? It’s sort of fun and you can create a new unique toy each time you repaint. It’s fun for the kids and I enjoy it too.
I will say that wood items sometimes stand up over time better…. but that’s not necessarily true. They certainly can rot or end up with bees nesting in them. And I think a coat or two of paint here or there tends to extend their lives as well.
I’m pretty brand loyal to Rustoleum, specifically the 2x spray paint that has primer included, at this point. I have not had good luck with other brands and quite frankly, I’m too lazy to want to be redoing old projects. Not a fan of redoing stuff. It’s not perfect, however. I still had some wear and tear on my playhouse.
In regard to that, I would recommend starting the project by priming the playhouse first. While the 2x has primer in it, the additional primer may help make this paint job last longer. I haven’t tested this theory yet though.
I’m still not sure if the UV spray did much, but it didn’t hurt… so there’s that. I didn’t see a lot of sun fading. It seems like a good idea to try.
I wouldn’t store these items on top of each other, like I did the buckets. If they’re stored in a way that scrapes the paint, it will scrape off.
Sunlight, snow, and the like will cause wear and tear to the paint job so storing the items in a shed or garage may extend their life. Or you can cover them with a tarp for winter.
Some toys may be used indoors which would substantially reduce the wear and tear they get (ie. the playhouse could be an indoor toy if you have room for it).
When I was discussing this post with my husband, we were checking out the old Little Tikes plastic slide that our in-laws saved to pass down. It’s probably 25 years old or so. The original colors were red, beige, and green. The beige, naturally, hasn’t truly faded. The green is slightly faded, but the red is badly faded.
Comparatively, we have a blue and yellow Little Tikes car. The blue is still going strong after a couple years, but the yellow top is quite faded. It’s a pretty huge difference. Looking at the bottom of the car, you’d think it was new (besides the peeling stickers). The top makes it look much older than it is.
The photo above is from a few years ago so it isn’t a good representation of the blue and yellow car.
Another plastic item is an orange chair. It’s also quite faded, although I think it may only be a year old.
This is all in regard to the original manufacturer colors which, given how they’re applied, should be more durable than a regular spray paint. The reason is that the colors were likely mixed into the plastic before it hardened, rather than being applied after. My husband mentioned that you can tell which color was the original color on many of our indoor toys too… you’ll notice that there’s one color that just doesn’t faded, but the other colors rub off after use (I’m thinking of those baby toys that get a lot of wear and tear).
This discussion had me curious about if the color affects how quickly a paint fades so I looked it up. It does. Reds tend to fade faster and blues don’t fade as fast. This makes sense when you look at the colors that I painted the playhouse. The dark blue has held up much better than the other colors. I found this reference.com article about which colors fade the fastest and my understanding is that shorter wavelength lights (blues, violet) are slower to fade than longer wavelength lights. This post from NASA about color wavelengths states that the colors range from shortest to longest wavelength in the following order: violet, blue, green, yellow, orange, and red.
Of course, we need to consider that paint colors are made by mixing different colors together so, for example, my light blue paint faded faster than the dark blue likely because it’s not a pure blue (and also because it’s on the roof and gets the most direct sunlight). Or at least that’s my theory… after all, to achieve the light blue, a lighter color would have been added to the primary blue by the paint manufacturer.
I needed to buy some new seat cushions for our porch chairs and I was almost about to grab some red ones when I thought of this post… and erred on side of caution and went for the blue pattern.
Technique might be the wrong word here. I’m not sure what else to call it. As stated above, I recommend trying a primer underneath. I doubt it will hurt.
Make sure to let each layer dry fully. It’d be ideal to do the painting in more temperate weather, rather than August when it’s beastly hot. I’m sure that doesn’t help the paint stay on.
I’m going to speak to the playhouse in particular… I loved all of the added detail to my playhouse that I added with the acrylic paints. It didn’t stand up very well over time. I’m not sure I would do it again for an outdoor playhouse, but it might work indoors.
My main complaint is that the playhouse would be much easier to reapply paint every year or two if the detailing wasn’t on it. I may redo the paint job on this, at which point I’ll cover up all of the acrylic work that I did. It’s a shame because it took me hours to do all of those details.